There are several measures to determine the quality of your research output. These include publishing in peer reviewed journals, using journal ranking lists and tracking citation data.
Quality journals are usually identified as those which have been peer-reviewed. Peer-review is a process of process of checking an author's scholarly work by others who are experts in the same field before they are accepted for publication.
To identify peer-reviewed journals:
- Search Ullrich's Periodicals Directory to see if a journal title has been peer reviewed.
- Check the editorial policy of individual journals, e.g. the Journal of Physiotherapy
- Thomson produces a free Master Journal List of journals indexed in its databases, which are peer reviewed.
- Many databases allow searches to be limited to peer reviewed journals only; check the online 'help' of individual databases for instructions on how to do this.
Journal rankings can also be used to identify quality journals.
Discipline-specific journal rankings lists are available:
- Accounting, Commerce, Finance
- AFAANZ provides lists of institutional journal rankings from a number of Australian and New Zealand Universities.
- Anne-Wil Harzing's Journal Quality List lists academic journals from Economics, Finance, Accounting, Management, and Marketing.
- Australian Business Deans Council ABDC Journal Quality List 2013
- Computer Education
- Information Systems
To find out when or how many times your publication has been cited, you need to check the available citation data.
The Web of Knowledge is a prime source of citation data, comprising four databases: the Science, Social Sciences, and Arts and Humanities Citation Indexes. Users are able to search current and retrospective information from approximately 8,500 of the most prestigious, high impact research journals in the world. It also lists how many times an article has been cited and who has sited it.
To find your own citation data:
- Go to the Web of Science database
- Go to Author Search (There is a little drop down arrow next to Basic Search, click on it and change to author search).
- Search your surname and first initial.
- Select Research Doman – leave blank.
- Select Organisation – Go to F and select all Flinders related institutions.
- Click on Finish search.
- Tick boxes that match your publications and then choose ‘Create Citation Report’.
- OR select create citation report and then remove individual items from the citation report (this might be easier depending on the number of publications).
If you noticed something is wrong with your Web of Science results
Web of Science gets its data from ResearcherID - you will need to create a profile at http://researcherid.com or update your existing profile.
Google Scholar also provides citation data for journal articles, but generally will return fewer results than Web of Knowledge. However, Google Scholar will also find citations in non-traditional formats such as academic web pages and pre-prints and will often identify new citations more quickly than Web of Knowledge.
- Go to Google Scholar
- Select Advanced Scholar Search (at the end of the search box)
- Enter the author’s name in the Return articles written by field
- Specify the relevant dates in Return articles published between field
- Select the subject area
- Click Search Scholar
- If the reference has been cited by others, a Cited by link will appear below the citation.
For help using any of the tools mentioned in this page, please contact your Liaison Librarian .